← All articles

Religion: The Architect of Inherited Guilt

Religion: The Architect of Inherited Guilt

The very foundation of the Abrahamic faiths is built upon the premise that we as humans are flawed, imperfect, in need of redemption, salvation, cleansing, purification and that the source of our ‘sin’ was a woman’s choice. This is most explicitly expressed within Christianity and its doctrine of the Fall; Judaism and Islam have different understandings of human imperfection, sin and responsibility, and do not share the Christian doctrine of inherited original sin in the same form, however, all of them demand purification through obedience.

This achieves a couple of things. Firstly it invents a disease and a flaw and then sells you the solution – obedience to a system of thought and practice that seeks to centralise power. Additionally, it creates an entire narrative in which the source of human suffering and ‘sin’ was caused by a woman’s desire to choose, question and reach for knowledge – and we’ve been living with the consequences of these teachings for countless generations. All of this sets up a systemic prison in which every individual, especially women, are policed and every rule, observance and restriction is authorised and presented as the path to cleanliness, holiness and goodness.

This fundamental story of guilt, or our wrongness, of our impurity has been codified and passed down like a poison chalice from generation to generation, even to the extent of telling us that the innocence of infancy is somehow unholy until water has been splashed upon its head or until a foreskin has been removed. This is ritualised possession – it is a claim of ownership upon the soul and sovereignty of an individual and states that those who step outside of this ritualised possession are in some way impure or are to be excluded. From a systemic point of view, religion has excluded and used the power of exclusion more than any other institution; it has been the most prolific and powerful engine of exclusion. Religion itself introduced exclusion as the norm at the level of the family and personal relationships for generations – countless individuals have been excluded from family systems in accordance with religious edicts – women excluded for their sexuality, women excluded for questioning, women excluded from the sacred, women deemed to be unclean, the exclusion of gay, lesbian and gender non-conforming individuals, and the rejection of mixed marriages.

This guilt still lives with us, not only because of all the exclusion that past generations were taught to participate in, but also because the very foundational teaching of the Abrahamic religions is that we are fundamentally 'guilty' by virtue of our existence. Hinduism and Buddhism are no better in this regard – in those systems we are in dire need of purification through multiple lives, trial by karma and ascent. These systems too frame the human experience as some sort of defect, the fundamental message that says that you are not fine, acceptable and good as you are – you’re in need of perpetual cleansing and purification. In the west we romanticise ‘eastern’ thought as peaceful antidotes to punitive western religious thinking, but they’re not – the fundamental message is the same: there is something wrong with you and I will determine exactly how and when and with whom you can rectify that. There’s not a single religious institution that allows us to simply exist as we are.

What religion does is to manufacture a flaw so that it can control and monopolise the remedy, and that usually starts with controlling women—a heavy price that has been paid by our mothers, grandmothers and great-grandmothers for generations. It has systematically erased individuals, removed our right to pleasure, introduced guilt as a weapon, and stripped away joy – it tells us what to wear, what to eat, how to eat and who is ‘more’ or ‘less’ spiritual according to these rules – all for the purpose of feeding a political hierarchy that seeks to control and oppress.

All of this is relevant to Family Constellation work because for generations religion has sanctified exclusion, and in addition, for generations children have surrendered their own innocence in order to be loyal to the ancestral poison chalice of guilt handed down to them—a guilt which also says that to reject religion is to betray the family system. We have been taught who to shun, who to reject, even who to hate.

Our inherited guilt is often a manifestation of the unexpressed grief, terror and self-hatred of those who had religious edicts visited upon them, with so many of us attempting to atone and redeem our lineage for the generations of sins and exclusions within the family system. Systemic healing invites us to step out of the field of damnation and guilt and impurity, include those who have been excluded, and embrace life freely as a guilt-free gift.

Systemic healing helps us to know that we are not in need of institutionalised redemption or cleansing in order to be whole; by offering us the full realisation of what has been handed down to us—pervasive guilt, pervasive blame, inherent misogyny, homophobia and the centralisation of knowledge and power—it affords us the freedom to question our internalised loyalties to a system of oppression for which we have all paid a heavy price.

The invitation here is to respectfully hand back the poison chalice of guilt, honouring the experience of our ancestors whilst at the same time reclaiming our innocence and disavowing the need for an intermediary to sanctify our lives – to take life fully, as it is, knowing that within our core is the human heart – inherently good, inherently generous, inherently kind – until we were repeatedly told for generations that we were bad and started to believe it. Tell someone often enough that they are bad and they will start to believe it, and once they believe it, badness flows and then you can hand them the remedy for the very poison you handed them. The circle of guilt and shame is complete; submission is achieved.

The truth of each and every human lies in the depths of the heart; without the heart, we lose one of the fundamentals of what it is to be human. We must unshackle ourselves from a generational system that has painted human experience as being inherently corrupt.

We must rise. Love is not a crime. It is who we are.

ALL CONTENT © Shavasti (John L. Payne). All rights reserved. You are welcome to freely quote and share this article, provided that full credit and attribution are explicitly given to the author and the original source: Shavasti (John L. Payne) — familyconstellations.net

Work with Shavasti

Private sessions online, family services and workshops held internationally throughout the year.